Back to All Episodes
Episode
96
37:14
November 22, 2026

From $300 SEO Jobs to a $6M EBITDA Exit: 17 Years Building Cardinal | Alex Membrillo

with
Alex Membrillo

Alex Membrillo was 24, about to become a father, and out of ideas. He had built a website and some eBay pages for his dad's pinball company in high school. So he asked his mechanic, Billy, a question: if I start a website company, will you buy one?

Billy said yes. Membrillo formed the company the day after his son was born and went back to collect his first customer.

Billy told him he was not buying a website from someone who did not know what he was doing.

That was the start of Cardinal Web Solutions. Seventeen years later, as Cardinal Digital Marketing, it was a healthcare performance marketing agency doing about $22 million in revenue and about $6 million in EBITDA. Power Digital announced the acquisition in January 2026, and Cardinal now operates as its healthcare division.

On Agency Acquisitions & Exits, Membrillo walked Peter Lang through the years in between: the cold calls, the collapse, the niche, and a sale process that drew about 40 indications of interest.

A hundred cold calls with a baby on his arm

With no first customer, Membrillo started dialing. A hundred cold calls a morning, holding a colicky newborn, hanging up when the baby cried and calling back to apologize.

He and his co-founder sold two websites. By his own account both looked terrible. So they switched to the only other thing they had seen a book about: SEO.

The first SEO client owned a kayak company. He asked whether they really knew SEO. Membrillo said yes, and offered the $300 back if it did not work. It worked. The client ranked in two weeks. The next project was $700. By the time Cardinal sold, it had clients paying a quarter of a million dollars a month.

He does not pretend there was a plan. "We didn't start out to make an agency. We started out to get this baby fed."

The takeaway: you do not need to know what you are doing to start, but you do need to keep calling.

Seventy percent of revenue, gone in 90 days

The mistake Membrillo would go back and change came early. Cardinal landed a very large client and grew from about half a million dollars to three and a half million in revenue. It felt like success. It lasted five years.

Then that client and a second large one left at the same time. Cardinal lost both within 90 days, and with them 70% of its revenue. Because the team had spent those years serving two accounts, it had no lead generation of its own to fall back on.

It took about five years to recover. He promised himself it would never happen again, and it mattered when he sold. At the time of the sale, his largest clients were no bigger than 13% of revenue.

"Client concentration matters for your sanity and for selling. That was my biggest lesson."

He now tells friends whose agencies are growing fast on one giant client that they are not really growing. They are collecting a lot of money from one customer, and that customer owns them.

The takeaway: one client paying most of your bills is a risk to the business and a discount on its sale price.

Stay in the weeds

Most advice to agency owners says to get out of the weeds, be the visionary, and hire a leadership team. Membrillo thinks that is the worst advice an owner can get.

His rule was not to hire anyone into leadership who would not spend about 80% of the day on client work. He stayed in it himself. He did marketing alongside the marketing team, went to every conference, wrote the follow-up emails, sat in sales meetings, and read every P&L and balance sheet.

When Cardinal sold, the company had no CFO and no COO. "There was no CFO. There was no COO."

He tried the other way first. He hired experienced outside leaders who wanted to direct work and not do it, and it failed. What worked was promoting from within. When consultants told him he needed a sales leader, he turned to his account team.

"Go look at your account managers and make them into your salesperson. They know all the stories."

The account manager he moved into sales was nervous about the switch. He calls her the best in the world at it and a big reason the agency grew. His head of client services and his paid media leader came up the same way.

The takeaway: at agency scale, leaders who do the work outperform leaders who only manage it.

Niche by building a lot of yes

Cardinal eventually focused on one vertical, healthcare. But Membrillo did not cut everything else off in one move, and he does not recommend it.

He started with five doorways: higher education, personal injury, other law firms, home services, and healthcare. Then he watched. Law and home services were crowded and the clients were hard. Healthcare had two big case studies behind it, and nobody else was doing performance marketing for large, private equity backed healthcare groups.

Saying no to money was hard. He admits he kept saying yes behind closed doors until his team called him on it. What made it possible was demand.

"The easiest way to say no is to build a lot of yes."

As healthcare leads grew, turning down other work stopped hurting. "I would not recommend just shutting one thing off."

The takeaway: build the pipeline in your niche first, and the no gets easy.

A marketing engine instead of referrals

Membrillo has little patience for agencies that are proud to grow on referrals alone. To him it means the owner has no control over growth.

Cardinal's early engine was SEO for its own name. It ranked first for Atlanta SEO terms, then for healthcare marketing agency terms. But search brought small leads. In 2020, stuck in a new office and unable to travel to conferences, he started a healthcare marketing podcast and invited the people he wanted to know. That grew into weekly content, an email list, and Cardinal's own conference.

The effect compounded. Cardinal used to spend 20% of revenue on marketing. By 2025 it was down to 5%, and leads were arriving faster than before.

"It's a lot cooler to say that we have a marketing pipeline that can build us from three to seven to ten million dollars in the next three years."

The takeaway: referrals are welcome, but a pipeline you control is what lets you scale and what a buyer pays for.

Keep growing while you sell

Membrillo had taken calls from bankers, private equity firms, and strategic buyers for years. He knew most of the CEOs in his space before any process began. The banker who stayed closest was Tom O'Connor of Canaccord Genuity, who kept telling him the agency was worth more than he thought.

When Membrillo was ready, O'Connor gave him the advice he calls the most accurate of the whole process: keep growing.

"If the EBITDA number and the revenue numbers go up every single time we talk and have to send over a new data book or whatever, you can dictate terms."

Cardinal started the process at about $3.2 million in EBITDA with addbacks, after a sell-side quality of earnings. By the end of that year it was at $6 million. Each time a bidder raised a concern, Membrillo could point to a higher number.

The sell-side QoE cost about $50,000. He says owners balk at the price and should not. It showed him what to fix before buyers found it, and it surfaced more addbacks than he expected.

Peter added the buyer's view: if you skip it, the surprises come after you accept an offer, and the upside goes to the buyer.

The takeaway: the strongest negotiating tool in a sale is a number that keeps rising.

Say nothing in the management meetings

Buyers wanted two things from Cardinal. The first was growth vectors: areas such as health systems and telehealth where Cardinal had a few clients and a buyer could invest to win more. The second was proof the business would run without its founder.

Membrillo's way of proving it was to stay quiet. Through 20, 30, 40 management meetings, three hours each, he let his leaders answer everything. "I wouldn't say a word."

Buyers saw a team that ran the day to day. It was true, and it is what happened after the close.

The takeaway: let your team carry the room, because a buyer is deciding whether the company works without you.

Forty IOIs and one choice

Some private equity firms passed early. Then about 40 indications of interest arrived. Cardinal ruled out half, received more than 10 letters of intent, and seriously considered five. The top two were close.

One would have made Cardinal a platform with Membrillo as CEO, reporting to a board for the first time in his life. The other was Power Digital, a strategic backed by private equity. He chose Power Digital. After 17 years he was tired, and he was honest with the other bidder about it once he was sure.

He also trusted that Power Digital would close. "I believed in their conviction more than anything."

One surprise: he expected the best offers to come from other healthcare agencies. He spent a lot of time meeting them. None made a solid offer. The interest came from buyers who had no healthcare practice and wanted one. "So keep your options open."

The takeaway: you cannot predict your buyer, so run a process wide enough to find them.

After the close

Membrillo says the selling year nearly broke his health, and that getting to the other side let him recover it. What he did not expect was the quiet. Nobody emails. "You're totally irrelevant on day two."

His advice to owners now is blunt: move fast, because the model that worked for the last decade may not last. Scale hard, or stay small on purpose. And his advice to his younger self is to take less advice. "Turn the advice off and just get to work."

The takeaway: decide which agency you are building, then build it without waiting for permission.

Listen to the Full Conversation

Alex Membrillo's full conversation with Peter Lang covers the first cold calls, the niche, the sale process, and his view of where AI leaves agencies. Watch it on YouTube or listen on Spotify.

‍

Heading 1

Heading 2

Heading 3

Heading 4

Heading 5
Heading 6

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.

Block quote

Ordered list

  1. Item 1
  2. Item 2
  3. Item 3

Unordered list

  • Item A
  • Item B
  • Item C

Text link

Bold text

Emphasis

Superscript

Subscript

About

Alex Membrillo

Founder of Cardinal Digital | Healthcare Aficionado | 40 not under 40 | Exited to Court Square Capital in 2025

More Episodes

Episode
95
-
40:13

Paul McEnany on Taking a Strategic Investment After 10 Years

with
Paul McEnany
Episode
93
-
40:25

Seven Deals in Twenty Years: How Jeff Hahn Built a $20M Agency Without Starting One

with
Episode
92
-
44:31

David Rodnitzky Sold the Same Agency Three Times. Here's What Each Buyer Taught Him.

with
David Rodnitzk
Get the Free

21-Day Agency M&A
Email Course

One short lesson a day to help you think like a buyer. Learn how agency acquisitions actually work, deal flow, valuation, risk, and structure, so you can build a sellable agency and exit on your terms.
✓  Deal sourcing playbook (how to find real opportunities)
✓  Valuation + risk framework (what to look for fast)
✓  Deal structures that protect cash flow (earnouts, seller finance, terms

Start the Free 21-Day Course

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.