Paul McEnany gets the same messages every agency owner with some scale gets. A LinkedIn note. A random email. A text. Wouldn't you love to sell your business?
He ignored almost all of them. Either the sender did not look credible, or he was not in that headspace. Then one came through that was different. He did not reply right away. He looked up who the person was first, and realized this was a legitimate, interesting company.
"So maybe we should at least talk to them and find out what they have to say, because I have no idea."
That curiosity started a journey of about a year and a half. It ended in February 2026, when Plein Air, the Dallas-based marketing, technology, and data consultancy McEnany runs with co-CEO Jason Abelkop, announced a strategic investment from Coral Tree Partners, a Los Angeles private equity firm. Canaccord Genuity advised Plein Air on the deal.
McEnany did not sell the company and walk away. He is still running it. On Agency Acquisitions & Exits, he walked Peter Lang through how an owner who was not trying to sell ended up with a financial partner, and what he learned along the way.
A decade with one bank account
Plein Air started in 2016. For ten years it took no outside investment. McEnany has friends who run venture-backed businesses at a loss. That was never an option for him and Abelkop.
"We have one bank account and I know how much money's in the bank account," he said. "There's only so much you can spend."
That limit shaped everything. The company did not plan around revenue per employee or EBITDA per employee. It planned around goals. What can we actually build with the people and the money we have?
Along the way Plein Air became an unusual business. It has an agency side that makes and buys ads and runs influencer work. It has a data team in the middle. And it has an e-commerce platform that McEnany describes as "like Squarespace but built around restaurants," made for enterprise restaurant brands.
The technology came early. One of the founders had a technology background, and three or four months in, the team was already building custom tools. They over-delivered on every project. McEnany admits that was "probably not great from a business model," but it sped up the company. Around 2019 they started rethinking how they built, because the old way was too expensive for most clients. By his account, 2022 is when the platform side "really started ripping."
The agency also owned that technology instead of handing it to clients. As Peter pointed out in the conversation, that matters a great deal to a buyer or investor.
The takeaway: constraints forced discipline, and owning the technology gave the company something an investor could underwrite.
We don't know what we're doing
By the time serious conversations began, Plein Air had 75 or 80 people. McEnany says the questions from outsiders were useful on their own. For years the team had been muscling the business from problem to problem. Having people ask about the company made the two partners think about what they wanted from it and how to structure it going forward.
They also saw the competition clearly. In every segment where Plein Air plays, it competes with companies that are very well funded. To win, he said, "we gotta be tight, we gotta be smart, and we also need access to capital that we don't have today."
Here is the part most owners get wrong. McEnany liked the people who first reached out. He spent a lot of time with them and thinks they would have been compatible. He still did not do a deal with them.
"We don't know what we're doing. So we need people on our team that do know what they're doing. And we need to get ourselves right from that standpoint before we go down this process. Otherwise, we're just gonna get our asses kicked in this."
So they asked their network for recommendations, had unhurried conversations with several advisory teams, and chose Canaccord Genuity because the team had deep experience in exactly Plein Air's space. There was no fire. Nobody was racing a deadline.
The takeaway: an inbound offer is a reason to get expert help, not a reason to negotiate alone.
Three people knew
A sale or investment process takes an enormous amount of time. McEnany and Abelkop decided early how to split it. Abelkop took the mechanics of getting the company ready. McEnany stayed on the business and made sure the day to day did not slip.
He credits the co-CEO structure. The two think about problems in very different ways and have different skills, but they tend to land in the same place. When one is better at something, the other lets him make the call. And each knows the other has his back.
They also kept the circle small. "There were three people at the company in total who knew it was happening for the vast majority of the process, largely because we didn't want it to be a distraction."
More people came in as the process moved later. But the principle held. In McEnany's view, distraction can kill a company.
The takeaway: decide who runs the deal and who runs the business before the process starts, and protect the team from the noise.
Investors are not clients
Plein Air pitches for a living. McEnany walked in confident about who the company was and how it sells. What it did not have was the financial side of that story.
"It's different when you're talking to investors than clients," he said. The advisors helped shape a more complete story of who the company was and how it was different, with someone in the room who understood what the market was looking for.
On the numbers, he is plain about it. Before the process, the test was simple: is the business healthy, is it making money, and is there enough cash on hand to handle something crazy? The change was about depth of reporting, access to the numbers, and what goes in what bucket.
Peter asked how they presented R&D, since a company that over-delivers and builds technology can look expensive through a return lens. The answer was to not get clever. "What is the standard way to do this? Let's do it that way."
Asked for the lesson other owners can take, McEnany did not dress it up. "I don't know if there's a single core lesson other than don't just wing it."
The takeaway: you do not need to become a finance expert, but you do need people at the table who are.
A year and a half, start to finish
The timeline is useful for any owner wondering how long this takes.
The first outreach came six months to a year before the banker conversations started. The banker conversations began about a year before the deal closed. The first round of the roadshow, taking interested groups through the deck, happened around July. McEnany remembers doing those calls from Montana, a few days of conversation after conversation. In-person meetings with the groups that advanced were around September. Diligence followed. The deal was finalized at the beginning of February.
Peter noted that a year for a banked process is right on par, with the time before that depending on how long the owner takes to decide.
The takeaway: plan on about a year once you hire an advisor, and longer from the first conversation.
Willing to walk away
McEnany says he and Abelkop had an advantage. They did not need one specific outcome.
"We need to walk into this being willing to walk away if it's not right."
They did not go in saying minority only, or majority only, or a full sale. They went in to learn what the options were and decide what made sense. McEnany says he has never needed a certain title or a certain ownership percentage. He wants to work on interesting problems with smart, driven people.
That openness met a range of buyers. Some arrived with a fixed playbook. Plein Air did not go with any of those. "Thank you for your playbook. But we're not a plumbing company." Others were technology-first groups who understood one part of the business and not the rest.
The filter came down to two questions. Who is best able to help unlock the value of the company while letting the team keep running it? And what stands in the way of growth, and who is best suited to move it?
The takeaway: knowing what you want the company to be is the only way to compare offers that look nothing alike.
Why Coral Tree
Coral Tree was in the first round of groups and pulled ahead for the reasons above. McEnany says they were smart and thoughtful about the potential of the business, a solid partner on how to structure the financial side, and good people.
The deciding factor was how they would behave when things got hard. Every company has stretches where everything clicks and stretches that are a slog. He wanted partners who would not say "things are crunchy, what did you do wrong?" and would say, in his words, "let's get together and let's talk about how to fix it."
On acquisitions, Coral Tree's message was that everything is on the table and the goal is to find the right thing. McEnany did not want an investor who would buy a pile of companies just to get bigger.
"We wanna be a bigger and better company."
The takeaway: pick the partner for the hard quarters, not the good ones.
Building in the age of AI
Peter closed on AI. When the investor conversations happened, McEnany says the company was dabbling like everyone else. Then, around March and April, the models got far better, and the thinking changed from small experiments to restructuring the company.
His view is that using a chat window well does nothing for a company. AI has to be part of how the work gets built. For Plein Air that means codifying how the company thinks and works, with automatic checks, so quality holds as the pace rises.
It also changes management. Plein Air has always kept middle management as thin as possible and pushed decisions to the edges. "That is a management layer," he said of the systems they are building now. "It's just a different kind of management layer."
Asked what he is most excited to build next, he said nearly everything, from internal project management to the platforms themselves. "It's never been a better time to be a builder."
The takeaway: the firms that win will rebuild how the work is done, not just add tools.
Listen to the Full Conversation
Paul McEnany's full conversation with Peter Lang covers the first message, the banker search, the roadshow, and how Plein Air chose its partner. Watch it on YouTube or listen on Spotify.
