When it comes to agency acquisitions, most owners assume the best opportunities are listed with brokers or marketplaces. The truth? By the time a deal is “on the market,” it’s already competitive, and often overpriced.

The best acquisitions are usually off-market deals: opportunities sourced directly from agency owners who haven’t formally listed their business for sale. These deals are quieter, less competitive, and often more flexible in structure.

Why Off-Market Deals Are Better

Off-market deals, by their very nature, bypass the traditional brokerage and public listing processes, offering a unique set of benefits that can significantly enhance a buyer’s position. These advantages extend beyond mere financial considerations, encompassing strategic alignment, relationship building, and overall deal flexibility.

Less Competition: A Clear Path to Acquisition

One of the most compelling reasons to pursue off-market opportunities is the drastic reduction in competition. In a publicly listed scenario, you’re often thrust into a bidding war, potentially competing against a multitude of other interested buyers. This can drive up prices, complicate negotiations, and even lead to missed opportunities. Off-market, however, the playing field is significantly smaller, often limited to a handful of discreetly approached potential buyers. This allows for a more focused and less frantic negotiation process, increasing your chances of securing the deal without the pressure of a crowded market. It empowers you to approach the acquisition from a position of strategic intent rather than reactive bidding.

Better Terms: Flexibility in Negotiation and Structure

When a seller has not “shopped” their business around, they are typically more flexible on the deal terms and structure. In a competitive, on-market sale, sellers often feel compelled to adhere to rigid terms to maintain a perception of control and value. Conversely, in an off-market setting, the absence of multiple offers and the direct, private nature of the conversation foster an environment of greater openness. This translates to the potential for more creative deal structures, such as earn-outs, deferred payments, or seller financing, which can be mutually beneficial. This flexibility allows buyers to craft terms that align better with their capital structure and risk appetite, and sellers to achieve their desired outcome with a more tailored approach.

Stronger Relationships: Building Trust from the Outset

Initiating the conversation directly with the business owner, rather than through an intermediary, fundamentally changes the dynamic of the deal. This direct communication fosters trust and a stronger relationship from the very beginning. In a traditional market, much of the initial communication is filtered through brokers, which can sometimes create a barrier. Off-market, you have the opportunity to understand the seller’s motivations, concerns, and long-term vision for their business firsthand. This personal connection can be invaluable, not only in closing the deal but also in ensuring a smoother transition post-acquisition. When a seller feels confident in the buyer’s understanding of their business and their intentions, they are more likely to be accommodating and cooperative throughout the process.

More Strategic Fit: Precision in Acquisition Targeting

Perhaps one of the most powerful aspects of off-market deals is the ability to proactively target agencies that precisely align with your growth strategy. Instead of reacting to whatever businesses happen to be listed on the market, you can conduct in-depth research to identify specific agencies that possess the unique attributes you’re seeking—whether it’s a particular niche, client base, geographic presence, or specialized expertise. This proactive approach ensures that every acquisition contributes directly and meaningfully to your overall strategic objectives, rather than merely adding to your portfolio. It allows for a more deliberate and effective expansion, building a stronger and more cohesive business over time.

Here’s how you can source off-market deals and create opportunities most buyers never even see.

1. Build a Target List

Start by identifying the types of agencies you want to acquire. Consider:

• Service capabilities you want to add
  
• Industries or verticals where you want to expand
  
• Geographic markets that make sense for your clients

From there, build a database of 50–200 potential targets. LinkedIn, Clutch, agency directories, and industry associations are great starting points.

Pro Tip: Aim for specificity. “Creative agencies under $5M revenue specializing in B2B SaaS” is far better than “any digital agency.”

2. Use Direct Outreach

The most effective way to source off-market deals is often the simplest: reach out directly.

• Personalized emails that highlight why you’re reaching out
  
• LinkedIn connection requests and messages
  
• Warm introductions from mutual contacts
  

The key is to keep it human. Don’t pitch them on selling in your first message. Start a conversation about their agency, their goals, and the future.

Watch-Out: Spray-and-pray outreach gets ignored. Targeted, relevant outreach gets results.

3. Leverage Relationships & Referrals

Many off-market opportunities come through your network:

• Industry peers and mastermind groups
  
• Advisors (lawyers, accountants, consultants)
  
• Former colleagues or employees
  

Let your network know you’re looking. The best introductions often come from people who already know and trust both sides.

4. Become a Thought Leader in the Space

The more visible you are, the more deals come to you. Share your perspective on M&A and agency growth publicly through:

• LinkedIn content
  
• Podcasts or guest appearances
  
• Speaking at industry events
  

When agency owners see you as a trusted voice, they’ll often approach you directly—sometimes years before they’re formally ready to sell.

5. Use Data & Tools to Spot Opportunities

Sometimes the best targets are hiding in plain sight. Look for signals that an agency might be open to a conversation:

• Flat or declining growth in public case studies or social posts
  
• Leadership transitions or succession challenges
  
• Recent client or employee turnover
  

Agency databases, LinkedIn Sales Navigator, and even job postings can reveal these signals.

6. Play the Long Game

Most owners aren’t ready to sell the first time you connect. That’s okay. Off-market sourcing is about planting seeds.

• Stay in touch through quarterly check-ins
  
• Share helpful insights or resources
  
• Build genuine relationships, not just deal pipelines
  

When the time comes, you’ll be the first person they call.

Off-Market = Real Opportunity

The best deals don’t show up in your inbox, they’re the ones you create. By targeting strategically, building relationships, and positioning yourself as a trusted partner, you can unlock opportunities that competitors never even know existed.

‍